One subject, in depth · bridged to Sideline US
FightIndex
Welterweight boxing · most active 1890s

Mysterious Billy Smith

37–25 · 85 recorded bouts · 1890–1915

Boxing record

37–25–27

Mysterious Billy Smith finished 65% of 37 wins inside the distance — the 66th percentile for welterweight boxing, where the median is 54%. No reach is on record, so this page compares record rather than measurements.

189019001910draw v Ed Harvey, 1890, decisionwin v Frank Tebeau, 1891, kowin v Danny Needham, 1892, kowin v Billy (Shadow) Maber, 1892, kowin v Charles Gleason, 1892, kodraw v Tommy West, 1892, decisionwin v Billy Armstrong, 1892, kowin v Frank Kelly, 1892, koloss v Frank Purcell, 1892, decisionwin v Billy Kelly, 1892, decisionwin v Billy McCarthy, 1893, decisiondraw v Tommy Ryan, 1893, decisionwin v Tom Williams, 1893, kodraw v Jack Powers, 1894, decisiondraw v Dick O'Brien, 1894, decisionloss v Mayo, 1894, koloss v Tommy Ryan, 1894, decisionwin v Eddie Butler, 1894, kowin v Fletcher Robbins, 1894, koresult not stated v Tom Cawley, 1895draw v Tommy Ryan, 1895, decisionresult not stated v Jimmy Mann, 1895win v Ed Vaughn, 1895, kowin v Young Hagen, 1895, kodraw v Barbados Joe Walcott, 1895, decisionresult not stated v Peter Maher, 1895win v Harry Gallagher, 1895loss v Tommy Ryan, 1896, dqloss v Australian Jim Ryan, 1896, dqresult not stated v Billy Gallagher, 1896loss v Charles Kid McCoy, 1896, dqwin v Bill Husbands, 1896, kowin v Trooper Ham, 1896, kowin v Jack Bryan, 1896, kowin v Arthur Morris, 1896, dqwin v Pat Kehoe, 1896, kowin v Johnny Gorman, 1897, dqwin v Billy Mulligan, 1897, koloss v Jack Bonner, 1897win v Jack Howard, 1897, kowin v Mike Dempsey, 1897, kodraw v Jack Powers, 1897, decisionwin v Abe Ullman, 1897, decisionloss v George "Young Corbett" Green, 1897, kodraw v Con Doyle, 1897, decisionwin v Barbados Joe Walcott, 1898, decisiondraw v Tommy West, 1898, decisionwin v Charlie McKeever, 1898, decisionwin v Jim Judge, 1898, kodraw v Andy Walsh, 1898, decisionwin v Matty Matthews, 1898, decisionwin v George "Young Corbett" Green, 1898, decisionloss v Billy Stift, 1898, dqdraw v Charley Johnson, 1898, decisionloss v Tim Callahan, 1898draw v Abe Ullman, 1898, decisionwin v Charlie McKeever, 1899, decisiondraw v Billy Stift, 1899, decisionwin v Bob Douglass, 1899, kodraw v Andy Walsh, 1899, decisionwin v Young Bailey, 1899draw v Jack Mahoney, 1899, drawwin v George Lavigne, 1899, kowin v Australian Billy Edwards, 1899, konc v Jack Mahoney, 1900draw v Professor Mike Donovan, 1900, decisionloss v Jim Judge, 1900, dqloss v Barbados Joe Walcott, 1900, dqwin v Young Peter Jackson, 1900, koloss v Jimmy Handler, 1900, decisionloss v Matty Matthews, 1900, kowin v Frank McConnell, 1900, dqloss v Rube Ferns, 1900, dqdraw v Al Neill, 1901, decisiondraw v Tom Tracey, 1901, decisiondraw v George Byers, 1901, decisionloss v Young Peter Jackson, 1901, kodraw v Tim Hurley, 1901, decisiondraw v Owen Ziegler, 1901, decisionloss v Tommy Ryan, 1902, koloss v Al Neill, 1902, dqloss v Barbados Joe Walcott, 1903, kowin v Al Neill, 1910, decisionloss v Jim Cameron, 1911, dqloss v Jack Root, 1915, ko
WON ABOVE·LOST BELOW BAR = STOPPAGE·BROKEN BAR = SUBMISSION·TICK = DECISION 1890–1915

SOURCE·Mysterious Billy Smith — English Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0)·derived figures computed here·REVIEWED 2026-07-07

How this record is compiled

  1. Measurements come from the fighter's English Wikipedia infobox; the bout list is parsed from the results table on the same article, read on 2026-07-07. Boxing tables are read by header name and MMA records by the fixed column order of the MMA record template — two different parsers, because reading MMA rows as a boxing table returns a fighter's boxing record in place of their real one.
  2. A bout enters the ledger with whatever fields the source states: result, opponent, method, round, year. Any field the source leaves empty stays empty here. A date that cannot be established is left blank rather than inferred, and the bout is still counted.
  3. A no contest is counted and printed as a no contest. It is never folded into the wins, the losses or the draws, and it never disappears to make a total balance.
  4. Where the article's infobox total disagrees with its own results table, both figures are published and each is labelled with where it came from. Nothing is averaged and nothing is reconciled against a second database.
  5. Percentiles rank this fighter among the 292 welterweight boxing fighters in the dataset — the most specific group of at least 30 that this fighter belongs to.

Sources, exclusions and known limits →

Bout record

Every bout the article's own results table lists, in order. A dash is a field the source leaves empty — it is not a zero and it is not a guess.

Bout-by-bout recordAUG 2026
YearResultOpponentMethodRd
1915 L Jack Root KO/TKO6
1911 L Jim Cameron DQ3
1910 W Al Neill Decision10
1903 L Barbados Joe Walcott KO/TKO4
1902 L Tommy Ryan KO/TKO4
1902 L Al Neill DQ10
1901 D Al Neill Decision20
1901 D Tom Tracey Decision20
1901 D George Byers Decision15
1901 L Young Peter Jackson KO/TKO2
1901 D Tim Hurley Decision20
1901 D Owen Ziegler Decision10
1900 N Jack Mahoney —11
1900 D Professor Mike Donovan Decision20
1900 L Jim Judge DQ11
1900 L Barbados Joe Walcott DQ10
1900 W Young Peter Jackson KO/TKO18
1900 L Jimmy Handler Decision25
1900 L Matty Matthews KO/TKO19
1900 W Frank McConnell DQ21
1900 L Rube Ferns DQ21
1899 W Charlie McKeever Decision20
1899 D Billy Stift Decision6
1899 W Bob Douglass KO/TKO4
1899 D Andy Walsh Decision25
1899 W Young Bailey —4
1899 D Jack Mahoney Draw6
1899 W George Lavigne KO/TKO14
1899 W Australian Billy Edwards KO/TKO14
1898 W Barbados Joe Walcott Decision20
1898 D Tommy West Decision20
1898 W Charlie McKeever Decision25
1898 W Jim Judge KO/TKO20
1898 D Andy Walsh Decision25
1898 W Matty Matthews Decision25
1898 W George "Young Corbett" Green Decision25
1898 L Billy Stift DQ5
1898 D Charley Johnson Decision15
1898 L Tim Callahan —6
1898 D Abe Ullman Decision8
1897 W Johnny Gorman DQ5
1897 W Billy Mulligan KO/TKO2
1897 L Jack Bonner —6
1897 W Jack Howard KO/TKO9
1897 W Mike Dempsey KO/TKO2
1897 D Jack Powers Decision8
1897 W Abe Ullman Decision20
1897 L George "Young Corbett" Green KO/TKO12
1897 D Con Doyle Decision12
1896 L Tommy Ryan DQ9
1896 L Australian Jim Ryan DQ7
1896 ? Billy Gallagher —1
1896 L Charles Kid McCoy DQ6
1896 W Bill Husbands KO/TKO8
1896 W Trooper Ham KO/TKO1
1896 W Jack Bryan KO/TKO1
1896 W Arthur Morris DQ1
1896 W Pat Kehoe KO/TKO1
1895 ? Tom Cawley —6
1895 D Tommy Ryan Decision18

Showing 60 of 85 recorded bouts, most recent first.

18 of these opponents have their own page here.

SOURCE·Mysterious Billy Smith — English Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0)·derived figures computed here·REVIEWED 2026-07-07

What is on record

Measurements
Reachnot recorded
Height68″ (172.7 cm)
Stance—
DivisionWelterweight Boxing
Most active decade1890s — 64 of 85 dated bouts
CountryCanada

Wikipedia carries no reach figure for Mysterious Billy Smith, so the reach-advantage comparison this site is built on cannot be computed. Everything below comes from the record instead.

1890 1900 1910 draw vs Ed Harvey (1890)win vs Frank Tebeau (1891)win vs Danny Needham (1892)win vs Billy (Shadow) Maber (1892)win vs Charles Gleason (1892)draw vs Tommy West (1892)win vs Billy Armstrong (1892)win vs Frank Kelly (1892)loss vs Frank Purcell (1892)win vs Billy Kelly (1892)win vs Billy McCarthy (1893)draw vs Tommy Ryan (1893)win vs Tom Williams (1893)draw vs Jack Powers (1894)draw vs Dick O'Brien (1894)loss vs Mayo (1894)loss vs Tommy Ryan (1894)win vs Eddie Butler (1894)win vs Fletcher Robbins (1894)? vs Tom Cawley (1895)draw vs Tommy Ryan (1895)? vs Jimmy Mann (1895)win vs Ed Vaughn (1895)win vs Young Hagen (1895)draw vs Barbados Joe Walcott (1895)? vs Peter Maher (1895)win vs Harry Gallagher (1895)loss vs Tommy Ryan (1896)loss vs Australian Jim Ryan (1896)? vs Billy Gallagher (1896)loss vs Charles Kid McCoy (1896)win vs Bill Husbands (1896)win vs Trooper Ham (1896)win vs Jack Bryan (1896)win vs Arthur Morris (1896)win vs Pat Kehoe (1896)win vs Johnny Gorman (1897)win vs Billy Mulligan (1897)loss vs Jack Bonner (1897)win vs Jack Howard (1897)win vs Mike Dempsey (1897)draw vs Jack Powers (1897)win vs Abe Ullman (1897)loss vs George "Young Corbett" Green (1897)draw vs Con Doyle (1897)win vs Barbados Joe Walcott (1898)draw vs Tommy West (1898)win vs Charlie McKeever (1898)win vs Jim Judge (1898)draw vs Andy Walsh (1898)win vs Matty Matthews (1898)win vs George "Young Corbett" Green (1898)loss vs Billy Stift (1898)draw vs Charley Johnson (1898)loss vs Tim Callahan (1898)draw vs Abe Ullman (1898)win vs Charlie McKeever (1899)draw vs Billy Stift (1899)win vs Bob Douglass (1899)draw vs Andy Walsh (1899)win vs Young Bailey (1899)draw vs Jack Mahoney (1899)win vs George Lavigne (1899)win vs Australian Billy Edwards (1899)nc vs Jack Mahoney (1900)draw vs Professor Mike Donovan (1900)loss vs Jim Judge (1900)loss vs Barbados Joe Walcott (1900)win vs Young Peter Jackson (1900)loss vs Jimmy Handler (1900)loss vs Matty Matthews (1900)win vs Frank McConnell (1900)loss vs Rube Ferns (1900)draw vs Al Neill (1901)draw vs Tom Tracey (1901)draw vs George Byers (1901)loss vs Young Peter Jackson (1901)draw vs Tim Hurley (1901)draw vs Owen Ziegler (1901)loss vs Tommy Ryan (1902)loss vs Al Neill (1902)loss vs Barbados Joe Walcott (1903)win vs Al Neill (1910)loss vs Jim Cameron (1911)loss vs Jack Root (1915)
winlossdraw / NC1890–1915

Record

Boxing record

37–25

94 bouts on record

Finish rate

65%

of wins ended inside the distance — welterweight boxing median 54%, 66th percentile

By knockout: 24 (65%)By decision: 13 (35%)
  • By knockout 65%
  • By decision 35%

The career, bout by bout

85 recorded bouts from 1890 to 1915. Every incumbent shows this as a table you have to read; here it is as a shape you can see.

Career span

26y

1890–1915

Longest unbeaten run

7

without a loss — draws do not break it

Busiest year

1898

11 bouts

Recorded bouts

85

85 with a date

Standing questions

What this record does and does not say

What is Mysterious Billy Smith's record?
37–25–27 in boxing. That is the aggregate stated in the English Wikipedia infobox; the results table on the same article lists 85 bouts individually.
Does a no contest change a record here?
No. A no contest is not a win, a loss or a draw, and it is never folded into one. It is counted and printed separately, so a 20–0 record with two no contests is shown as exactly that rather than as 22–0 or as 20–0 with the no contests dropped. The same applies to a bout overturned after the fact where the source records the change.
What happens when sources disagree about a fight?
This site publishes one source — the fighter's English Wikipedia article, read on the date printed under every table — and it does not silently reconcile that against anyone else's database. Where the article's own infobox total and its own results table disagree, both are shown and the page says which one each figure came from. Nothing is averaged, and no field is filled in from a second source to make a total balance.

See what every site in this family answers

Published by

Amit Sharma

Auckland real-estate agent and marketer. Builds free, sourced data tools.